Starting a Small Business:
How to Select a Franchise Business
Source: Managing
a Small Business
Using The Index/Profile
System
This section is not intended to convince anyone to
acquire a franchise. It is presented as an aid to those who have decided to invest in, or
who are seriously interested in investigating, one of the many franchise opportunities
available today. The material presented is an index of basic information a person should
have about a particular franchise to enable him to make a valid determination as to
whether or not a specific franchise is the right one for him and whether or not the
chances for returns both in terms of money and future are there. The section, in a
questionnaire format, should be used to profile and evaluate the franchises you are
investigating.
Franchising is a modern term for a more than fifty year old method of wholesale and
retail product distribution. Although most of the franchise opportunities now in business
have been started since 1954, franchising has been around for over a half of a century. It
started with the automobile manufacturers, brewers, soft drink bottlers and oil companies.
Now it has expanded to almost every kind of product or service, including business
services, food, education, clothing, pets, lodging, etc.
In the past several years franchise companies have received much interest from Wall
Street, not only because of the performance of franchise stocks, but also because of the
entrance of major blue chip companies into the franchise field.
Franchising can be an answer for the man who wants to go into business for himself. One
of the biggest mistakes you can make, however, is to be in a hurry to get into business.
Therefore, if you shortcut the information gathering and evaluation programs outlined in
this section, you might neglect to take a look at other franchises that are perhaps better
and more suitable than the one selected, or you might be "pressured" into a
franchise that is not right for you.
Although most franchises are managed by reputable businessmen, you should keep in mind
that some may be poorly managed and financially weak. Also, as in all industries, there
are those of questionable practices and those who have controls and restrictions that are
so one sided (in their favor) that they are unreasonable. This section is intended to
guide your franchise investigation in such a way that you can avoid involvement with those
who are not reputable.
Before getting into a thorough evaluation of any franchise, here is a quick test that
can save you much time, money and aggravation.
- Were you promised high profits in exchange for minimum effort?
- Did the representative pressure you to sign a contract immediately?
- Were you told that this was your last chance to sign and that if you did not, the
opportunity would no longer be available?
- Did the representative refuse to answer any questions or did he refuse to give specific
answers?
- Were you told of services such as training, management assistance, etc., without
specific examples of each?
- Was the representative reluctant to give you a responsible list of references?
- Did you feel that the representative was more interested in selling you a franchise than
he was in your being successful in business?
- Did the representative try to discourage you from having your attorney review the
contract before you signed it?
In addition, it might be wise for you to call or visit one of the operating franchises
and talk to the owner about his business and find out:
1. Does the franchisor deliver what he promises?
2. Based on the franchisee's experience with the franchisor does he consider him
competent in the business of the franchise and does he consider the company itself to be
well managed and responsive to franchisee's needs?
If the answer to questions 1- 8 are NO, and if you are satisfied with your discussion
with the franchisee, then proceeding with the FRANCHISE INDEX /PROFILE is the next step in
evaluating the franchise opportunity you are considering.
How To Use The Franchise Index/Profile
This section has been written in outline form so that it is
easy to relate information from the index to the profile and vice versa. The basis of the
section is a series of questions set up in major interest categories building one on the
other so that at the end of the question process you will have a fairly complete picture
of the franchise. You should have obtained a feel as to whether or not it is the right
franchise for you. Also, in the process you will have weeded out the bad risks from the
field of prospects.
Evaluating a franchise in the manner outlined in this section will take time and
patience but results will make it worthwhile. If the franchisor refuses, without good
reason, to go along with you in providing the information, be skeptical of his franchise.
On the other hand it is easy to get tired along the way and decide to shortcut the
questionnaire. A complete investigation of the business is the best way to insure against
failure or getting taken by an unethical company. The money you will invest in a franchise
has resulted from hard work. . . isn't it only proper to take time to determine the best
way to use it?
In the Franchise Index, you will find a series of questions along with an explanation
of what the answer should be and what it means or how to determine what the answer should
be for the franchise you are interested in.
For example, question A-1-a deals with the reputation of the product or service sold by
the franchisee. The logical answer is: ...Yes, I only want to deal in a business selling
reputable products or services. How do you know without checking that this is the case.
Naturally the franchisor will say his product or service is reputable; but is he telling
you the truth? The discussion of this question tells you how to find out the answer.
Did you know that many franchises are not exclusive? In fact you might find yourself
competing with the franchisor himself who is selling direct in a territory that you
thought was yours exclusively. Question A-9-a and discussion tells you how to find this
out.
In the Franchise Profile, the questions are repeated, this time, however, without the
discussion section. Instead there are blanks to be filled in. When completed, this forms
the profile of the franchise you are evaluating. It would be beneficial if you make your
decisions as to what you want in a franchise as you read through this section. You can
later use it as a check when you get into evaluating franchise prospects. You will find
that it will also force you to make some decisions that up until now you have avoided.
For example, (Question A-2-b deals with your time. Do you plan to spend full or part
time on the franchise? This is a basic decision you must make before becoming serious
about any franchise.
Question 4c asks, "Does the forecast of income provide for your personal
goals?" Here the answer includes an evaluation of the family budget plus the amount
of money required to run the business. This determines the income that must be generated
from the franchise.
Also, you should set up a file for each franchise you evaluate and keep in it all
materials you receive from the franchisor, copies of letters and replies used in checking,
and a written diary of all discussions you have with the franchisor. In the diary make
sure each entry is dated and the names of all persons in the meeting noted. Also, each
diary entry should record the purpose of the discussion, the information obtained, and any
action to be taken.
Franchise Index
A.
FRANCHISE - GENERAL
1. IS THE PRODUCT OR SERVICE
a. Considered reputable - What is the reputation of the company and its products or
services. Remember, a customer will buy the first time on the promise of quality, but will
not reorder if he does not get what was promised. To get the answer to this question talk
to people who are familiar with the product, check it out yourself.
b. Part of a growing market - The answer does not always have to be yes, since
many markets are on the borderline between slow growth and "taking off" What you
have to watch out for here is a declining market. The best place to check for information
on growth or near growth is request marketing data from the franchisor, check with your
broker, write to the trade magazine covering the market in question and check it out at
your local business library.
c. Needed in your area - It is very important that you get a yes here. A
snow-ski shop franchise would not go over too well in Florida. Make sure that the products
or services have year round appeal in your area as well as being needed.
d. Of interest to you - Only you can answer this, and it is important since
investment in a franchise should be viewed as a lifetime job. For example, if you enjoy
repairing automobiles, a related franchise such as a service station or a muffler shop
should be of interest. If you are a teacher, possibly a secretarial school or home study
school franchise would be of interest.
e. Safe, protected and guaranteed - If a product rather than a service is
involved be sure that it is safe, that it meets quality standards, and that there are no
restrictions upon its use. Is the product protected by patent or liability insurance and
is this same protection afforded to you as a franchisee? If a guarantee is involved,
obtain a copy and be sure of your responsibilities and obligations as a franchisee.
c. Carry the name of a well-known personality - This can be good or bad.
Assuming that the personality has and maintains a good reputation, it is important that he
or she have an actual investment as opposed to being a figurehead and make substantial
personal contributions of time and effort to promote the franchise to the mutual benefit
of all franchisees. Do not be fooled by a glamour name. Make sure that the basic franchise
is sound with or without the prominent name.
2. IS THE FRANCHISE
a. Local, regional, national or international - This answer is for information but
does have a direct relationship to the franchise fee and also to the future. Chances are
that a franchise that is now only local or regional is in the beginning or test stage and
will go national once the test has proved successful. The national and international
franchises are probably older and better established, also better known. The latter point
is important to you particularly if your product is a consumer one such as the fast food
or motel field.
b. Time requirements, part- or full-time - This depends on what you are looking
for. Unfortunately, there are very few part-time franchises that are as good as they
profess to be. Those that are good do involve a considerable amount of time if they are to
be successful. There is no shortcut to a second income.
Also it is highly doubtful that you can sit back, as some part-time franchises profess,
make some mailings, and watch the money roll in. Check the part-time franchises out just
as thoroughly. as the full-time one. Not all of the 100 questions will apply. If you do
get involved in a part-time endeavor, take a look and see whether or not it could later be
expanded into a profitable full-time venture. This is a good test. Full-time franchises
are what they say ...you have no other job and therefore no other income. Make sure that
you have at least 1 year or possibly 2 years personal financial reserve left after you pay
the franchise fee and put capital into your business. There are some franchises, usually
in the personal service field, that can be started on a part time basis with the full time
situation one or two years away.
3. EXISTING FRANCHISES
a. How long was the company in business before the first franchise was awarded -
This will tell you which came first ...the product idea or the desire to enter the
franchise field. Favor should be given to the company that started before it entered the
franchise business. A good example of why this is important is the value today of motel
franchises, automobile dealerships, and soft drink bottlers.
b. What date was the company founded and what date was the first franchise awarded
- Here we want to establish the period of time that the company was in business before it
went the franchise route of distribution. Keep in mind that the dates you want are related
to the franchise and not the parent company. In this day and age of mergers and
acquisitions many major franchises are owned by major corporations. It would also be
interesting to find out whether or not the original franchise is still in operation.
c. Number in operation and geographical spread - This will give you an idea as
to the popularity of the franchise. This information coupled with the preceding answer
will give you an idea as to whether or not this is an "overnight" growth pattern
or a gradual pattern. The gradual pattern tends to give more stability, that is if the
rate of failure is low. You should also find out whether or not there is a geographical
cluster ... that is, are there a major number of existing franchises in one specific area;
or are they evenly spread across the country. You will usually find a cluster around the
home office area of the franchise. A cluster can be expected in the early stages; but, if
a franchise claims to be national and if they have been in business three years or longer,
the spread should be fairly even.
The franchisor should provide you with the name and address of several franchises in
operation in markets like yours. For example, if your market is 60,000 in population you
should compare with another 60,000 market. Call or visit these locations (more notes), at
least one of which should be a relatively new franchise. Ask the questions that are of
greatest concern to you. Try to get a feel as to whether or not you would like the work,
could earn enough to support your family, etc.
d. Number planned next 12 months - Not all franchises will be able to give an
answer to this question, yet it is a key factor to future growth. In some cases the
attitude will be ...just as many as we can sell. In other cases a set objective has been
established. Keep in mind that part of what you pay for in the franchise fee is service,
advice, and training. If the home office is not planning properly they will not be geared
to give what they promise. Look for a definitive answer and ask the additional question
...What are your plans for adding home office personnel to continue the same level of
service, advice, and training for all franchises? Another way to look at future planning
is to realize that as the number of franchises increases so does the national visibility,
and this is as good as any advertising.
4. WHY HAVE FRANCHISES FAILED
a. How many franchises have failed - The number is not the most important factor
unless there is a high number in relation to the current number in operation. It would be
good to find out how many of the failures were in the past 2 years. If the failure rate is
high, perhaps the reasons have been corrected. If this is so, the failure rate would be
clustered prior to the past 2 years.
b. Why have franchises failed - This is one of the most important questions that
you can ask. It is also one of the most difficult for the franchisor to answer because it
reflects on the franchise program. The answer to this is found in two ways. First, ask the
franchisor why he thinks the franchises failed, have him list the reasons in order of
importance. Then, ask for the names and addresses of franchisees who have failed. Contact
them and ask the same question. Check the answers, if they agree, find out from the
franchisor if the reasons have been corrected. If the answers from the franchisee and
franchisor do not agree, discuss them with the franchisor and Find out why they do not
agree. Remember, in talking to the franchisee that failed that he will probably be biased
against the franchisor. On the other hand the franchisor might lay failure at the feet of
the franchisee. Use your own judgment in this case and draw your own conclusions.
5. FRANCHISE IN LOCAL MARKET AREA
a. Has a franchise ever been awarded in this area - As will be covered later, many
franchises (such as the multilevel distribution type) are on a nonexclusive basis, and
therefore the franchise you are investigating might already be in operation in your
market. This is not a negative, and, in fact, in the case of fast food and personal
service franchises it is better to have several per market as each benefits from the
visibility of the other. On the other hand, a franchise might have failed at some time in
the past in your area. You should know why. The final point in regard to this question is
the amount of interest on the part of others in this franchise in your area. If the
interest is high, that means that there is a pretty good chance that the general interest
level would be high on the part of customers. On the other hand, if the interest level is
low, this could be a negative. Ask the franchisor for the franchisee inquiry count from
your area. If there is a franchise in operation in your market, get the name and address
of the owner, visit with him and discuss the franchise. He should be glad to answer your
questions. Also, if there has been a failure get the name and address of the person
involved and talk to him too.
6. WHAT PRODUCT OR SERVICE WILL BE ADDED TO FRANCHISE PACKAGE
a. Within 12 months - This may be either the result of past planning or the result
of a need to improve sagging sales.
What you are looking for in this category is future growth. For example, in fast food
what new product has been added, in the case of a business service franchise has income
tax service been added, or have new courses been added to a school or home study program,
etc.
b. Within 2 years - What is now in the planning stages? Perhaps the franchisor
will not give specifics and this is understandable since this information would be of a
confidential nature. Reasonable and reassuring answers should be available however. What
you are looking for here are efforts to keep up with the market and its changing
conditions. For example, if the franchise involves automobiles, is the future in tune with
what is happening in that market with the problem of air pollution, etc.
c. Within 2 to 5 years - This would be more in corporate goals than in the
planning stages at this time. Ask what are the long range corporate goals for the
franchisor. See if they have thought beyond the next couple of years. This is important
because chances are that your competition is concerned with the future, if your franchise
is not, the future of your franchise could be dim.
7. COMPETITION
a. What would my competition be - For the answer to this turn to the Yellow Pages.
You might have to check more than one directory depending on the type of franchise you are
considering. For example, if it is a fast food restaurant you would be interested in only
the adjoining neighborhood: If the franchise is covering a wide area, you should check
directories covering the total area. Call your telephone company business office for
advice as to what directories cover the area and how to get them. Make a complete list of
competition listing addresses and telephone numbers of all locations. Visit several of the
major ones and observe appearance, traffic, and attempt to appraise the current situation.
Make notes for future reference. If the franchise looks particularly good, talk to the
manager and get the name of the franchisor. Write to them for the franchise package
...maybe it will be better than the one you are now investigating. The thing you want to
accomplish here is to get a feel for competition ...can you do the job? ...is the market
saturated with the product or service?
8. ARE ALL FRANCHISES INDEPENDENTLY OWNED
a. Are all outlets franchised or are some company owned - A recent development in
franchising is the situation where franchise companies are buying back franchises so that
stronger corporate control can be maintained. So far this has affected only major motel,
restaurant, and fast food chains. You should find out whether or not all outlets are
independent franchises. If not, how many are company owned. If there is evidence of recent
company repurchase, find out what the repurchase agreement is.
b. Date of most recent company acquisition - If the answer to this is a recent
date, then you are reasonably sure that a repurchase program is underway. That is unless
the franchise was repurchased or taken over for contract violation. In the event the
latter is the reason, it is not a negative but a strength indicating franchisor interest
and policing program.
9. FRANCHISE DISTRIBUTION PATTERN
A major distribution pattern in the franchise industry, for both products and services,
is the two-step method. Briefly, this means that the franchisor "packages" the
product and sells it to distributors who in turn sell it to dealers who in turn sell it to
the customer. The distributor usually covers a fairly large area. The dealer covers a very
local area, usually his "backyard market."
a. Exclusive vs. nonexclusive - This can be a surprise since many franchises,
contrary to what people think, are not exclusive as far as territory is concerned. In some
cases, both the distributor and franchisor retain the right to sell direct in the
franchisee territory. Also, they retain the right to sell more than one franchise in a
given territory. There is nothing wrong with a nonexclusive franchise providing you are
aware of the situation before you buy the franchise and want to work this way.
The obvious disadvantage of the nonexclusive franchise is a smaller sales potential.
This should be spelled out to your satisfaction in the contract.
b. Distributorship vs. dealership - Which one of these is your franchise? You
will find the distributorship costs considerably more than the dealership and at the same
time requires more business knowledge and leadership capabilities. If you do not have a
strong business background and financial reserves, stay away from the distributorship.
Start with a dealership. It will be close to home, require less capital, and your time
will be concentrated on the management of that particular location rather than a group of
locations. The return, however, from the dealership is usually less than from the
distributorship. If your franchise is a dealership, get the name and address of your
distributor, visit with him and see whether or not you can get along with him. It will be
the distributor with whom you will conduct much of your business not the
franchisor.
10. FRANCHISE OPERATIONS
Some franchises can be operated from the home, others require office space, others
manufacturing facilities, and others the actual construction of a building. If the
franchise requires office space or the construction of a building, make sure the
franchisor offers guidance and assistance as this is the most important initial role he
will play in getting your business started.
a. What facilities are required - Determine what is needed. This is usually very
evident in the literature that is provided about the franchise. Usually sales
organizations can be operated from home or from shared office space; personnel agencies
require leased office space; retail type franchises require leased store space; and most
fast food outlets and education type franchises require buildings that have to be
constructed.
b. Lease or build - In either situation there are things to look out for. For
example, a lease is usually signed for a specific period of time ..one year, two years,
etc. If it is a lease situation, be sure of the time involved. If the space leased is too
small and not expandable and your business grows to the point you need additional space
and your lease is not up, a penalty will be charged by the building management to break
the lease. Construction is a different situation and a different set of considerations.
Labor problems can delay completion, weather can be a major factor on completion, etc.
These are things that any Realtor can tell you about. You should talk to one you know.
c. Getting started - If your franchise requires that customers come to your
place of business (fast food outlets, home remodeling stores, income tax preparation,
etc.) the critical point of getting started and the pivotal point on the success of your
future business is the feasibility study. This should be done for you by the
franchisor;
if you are told to do it, view this as a negative. The feasibility study considers the
experience gained by the franchisor in setting up successful franchises and applies it to
your market. For example, the following information would be developed and evaluated:
traffic count of various location possibilities, average income of the area, number of
target prospects in the area (fast food would require high concentration of young
families, etc.), and other factors critical to the success of the franchise. Part
experience of the franchisor will tell what is required to assure the possible success of
the franchise. You should make sure that any money "put down" on the basis of
having the feasibility study conducted would be returned to you in the event the results
are negative.
d. Construction - If you must build, once again the franchisor should be
"your right hand man." In fact, he should guide you every step of the way. In
checking what you get for the franchise fee you will find most times that this type of
service is a major reason for a fee at all. If not offered, consider it a negative. Here
you are getting into architecture and design landscaping, contract award, construction,
decor and furnishing, and financing. The subject of financing is critical and will be
covered in Section C-FINANCIAL AND LEGAL. 1. IS THE PRODUCT OR SERVICE
a. Considered reputable - What is the reputation of the company and its products or
services. Remember, a customer will buy the first time on the promise of quality, but will
not reorder if he does not get what was promised. To get the answer to this question talk
to people who are familiar with the product, check it out yourself.
b. Part of a growing market - The answer does not always have to be yes, since
many markets are on the borderline between slow growth and "taking off" What you
have to watch out for here is a declining market. The best place to check for information
on growth or near growth is request marketing data from the franchisor, check with your
broker, write to the trade magazine covering the market in question and check it out at
your local business library.
c. Needed in your area - It is very important that you get a yes here. A
snow-ski shop franchise would not go over too well in Florida. Make sure that the products
or services have year round appeal in your area as well as being needed.
d. Of interest to you - Only you can answer this, and it is important since
investment in a franchise should be viewed as a lifetime job. For example, if you enjoy
repairing automobiles, a related franchise such as a service station or a muffler shop
should be of interest. If you are a teacher, possibly a secretarial school or home study
school franchise would be of interest.
e. Safe, protected and guaranteed - If a product rather than a service is
involved be sure that it is safe, that it meets quality standards, and that there are no
restrictions upon its use. Is the product protected by patent or liability insurance and
is this same protection afforded to you as a franchisee? If a guarantee is involved,
obtain a copy and be sure of your responsibilities and obligations as a franchisee.
c. Carry the name of a well-known personality - This can be good or bad.
Assuming that the personality has and maintains a good reputation, it is important that he
or she have an actual investment as opposed to being a figurehead and make substantial
personal contributions of time and effort to promote the franchise to the mutual benefit
of all franchisees. Do not be fooled by a glamour name. Make sure that the basic franchise
is sound with or without the prominent name.
2. IS THE FRANCHISE
a. Local, regional, national or international - This answer is for information but
does have a direct relationship to the franchise fee and also to the future. Chances are
that a franchise that is now only local or regional is in the beginning or test stage and
will go national once the test has proved successful. The national and international
franchises are probably older and better established, also better known. The latter point
is important to you particularly if your product is a consumer one such as the fast food
or motel field.
b. Time requirements, part- or full-time - This depends on what you are looking
for. Unfortunately, there are very few part-time franchises that are as good as they
profess to be. Those that are good do involve a considerable amount of time if they are to
be successful. There is no shortcut to a second income.
Also it is highly doubtful that you can sit back, as some part-time franchises profess,
make some mailings, and watch the money roll in. Check the part-time franchises out just
as thoroughly. as the full-time one. Not all of the 100 questions will apply. If you do
get involved in a part-time endeavor, take a look and see whether or not it could later be
expanded into a profitable full-time venture. This is a good test. Full-time franchises
are what they say ...you have no other job and therefore no other income. Make sure that
you have at least 1 year or possibly 2 years personal financial reserve left after you pay
the franchise fee and put capital into your business. There are some franchises, usually
in the personal service field, that can be started on a part time basis with the full time
situation one or two years away.
3. EXISTING FRANCHISES
a. How long was the company in business before the first franchise was awarded -
This will tell you which came first ...the product idea or the desire to enter the
franchise field. Favor should be given to the company that started before it entered the
franchise business. A good example of why this is important is the value today of motel
franchises, automobile dealerships, and soft drink bottlers.
b. What date was the company founded and what date was the first franchise awarded
- Here we want to establish the period of time that the company was in business before it
went the franchise route of distribution. Keep in mind that the dates you want are related
to the franchise and not the parent company. In this day and age of mergers and
acquisitions many major franchises are owned by major corporations. It would also be
interesting to find out whether or not the original franchise is still in operation.
c. Number in operation and geographical spread - This will give you an idea as
to the popularity of the franchise. This information coupled with the preceding answer
will give you an idea as to whether or not this is an "overnight" growth pattern
or a gradual pattern. The gradual pattern tends to give more stability, that is if the
rate of failure is low. You should also find out whether or not there is a geographical
cluster ... that is, are there a major number of existing franchises in one specific area;
or are they evenly spread across the country. You will usually find a cluster around the
home office area of the franchise. A cluster can be expected in the early stages; but, if
a franchise claims to be national and if they have been in business three years or longer,
the spread should be fairly even.
The franchisor should provide you with the name and address of several franchises in
operation in markets like yours. For example, if your market is 60,000 in population you
should compare with another 60,000 market. Call or visit these locations (more notes), at
least one of which should be a relatively new franchise. Ask the questions that are of
greatest concern to you. Try to get a feel as to whether or not you would like the work,
could earn enough to support your family, etc.
d. Number planned next 12 months - Not all franchises will be able to give an
answer to this question, yet it is a key factor to future growth. In some cases the
attitude will be ...just as many as we can sell. In other cases a set objective has been
established. Keep in mind that part of what you pay for in the franchise fee is service,
advice, and training. If the home office is not planning properly they will not be geared
to give what they promise. Look for a definitive answer and ask the additional question
...What are your plans for adding home office personnel to continue the same level of
service, advice, and training for all franchises? Another way to look at future planning
is to realize that as the number of franchises increases so does the national visibility,
and this is as good as any advertising.
4. WHY HAVE FRANCHISES FAILED
a. How many franchises have failed - The number is not the most important factor
unless there is a high number in relation to the current number in operation. It would be
good to find out how many of the failures were in the past 2 years. If the failure rate is
high, perhaps the reasons have been corrected. If this is so, the failure rate would be
clustered prior to the past 2 years.
b. Why have franchises failed - This is one of the most important questions that
you can ask. It is also one of the most difficult for the franchisor to answer because it
reflects on the franchise program. The answer to this is found in two ways. First, ask the
franchisor why he thinks the franchises failed, have him list the reasons in order of
importance. Then, ask for the names and addresses of franchisees who have failed. Contact
them and ask the same question. Check the answers, if they agree, find out from the
franchisor if the reasons have been corrected. If the answers from the franchisee and
franchisor do not agree, discuss them with the franchisor and Find out why they do not
agree. Remember, in talking to the franchisee that failed that he will probably be biased
against the franchisor. On the other hand the franchisor might lay failure at the feet of
the franchisee. Use your own judgment in this case and draw your own conclusions.
5. FRANCHISE IN LOCAL MARKET AREA
a. Has a franchise ever been awarded in this area - As will be covered later, many
franchises (such as the multilevel distribution type) are on a nonexclusive basis, and
therefore the franchise you are investigating might already be in operation in your
market. This is not a negative, and, in fact, in the case of fast food and personal
service franchises it is better to have several per market as each benefits from the
visibility of the other. On the other hand, a franchise might have failed at some time in
the past in your area. You should know why. The final point in regard to this question is
the amount of interest on the part of others in this franchise in your area. If the
interest is high, that means that there is a pretty good chance that the general interest
level would be high on the part of customers. On the other hand, if the interest level is
low, this could be a negative. Ask the franchisor for the franchisee inquiry count from
your area. If there is a franchise in operation in your market, get the name and address
of the owner, visit with him and discuss the franchise. He should be glad to answer your
questions. Also, if there has been a failure get the name and address of the person
involved and talk to him too.
6. WHAT PRODUCT OR SERVICE WILL BE ADDED TO FRANCHISE PACKAGE
a. Within 12 months - This may be either the result of past planning or the result
of a need to improve sagging sales.
What you are looking for in this category is future growth. For example, in fast food
what new product has been added, in the case of a business service franchise has income
tax service been added, or have new courses been added to a school or home study program,
etc.
b. Within 2 years - What is now in the planning stages? Perhaps the franchisor
will not give specifics and this is understandable since this information would be of a
confidential nature. Reasonable and reassuring answers should be available however. What
you are looking for here are efforts to keep up with the market and its changing
conditions. For example, if the franchise involves automobiles, is the future in tune with
what is happening in that market with the problem of air pollution, etc.
c. Within 2 to 5 years - This would be more in corporate goals than in the
planning stages at this time. Ask what are the long range corporate goals for the
franchisor. See if they have thought beyond the next couple of years. This is important
because chances are that your competition is concerned with the future, if your franchise
is not, the future of your franchise could be dim.
7. COMPETITION
a. What would my competition be - For the answer to this turn to the Yellow Pages.
You might have to check more than one directory depending on the type of franchise you are
considering. For example, if it is a fast food restaurant you would be interested in only
the adjoining neighborhood: If the franchise is covering a wide area, you should check
directories covering the total area. Call your telephone company business office for
advice as to what directories cover the area and how to get them. Make a complete list of
competition listing addresses and telephone numbers of all locations. Visit several of the
major ones and observe appearance, traffic, and attempt to appraise the current situation.
Make notes for future reference. If the franchise looks particularly good, talk to the
manager and get the name of the franchisor. Write to them for the franchise package
...maybe it will be better than the one you are now investigating. The thing you want to
accomplish here is to get a feel for competition ...can you do the job? ...is the market
saturated with the product or service?
8. ARE ALL FRANCHISES INDEPENDENTLY OWNED
a. Are all outlets franchised or are some company owned - A recent development in
franchising is the situation where franchise companies are buying back franchises so that
stronger corporate control can be maintained. So far this has affected only major motel,
restaurant, and fast food chains. You should find out whether or not all outlets are
independent franchises. If not, how many are company owned. If there is evidence of recent
company repurchase, find out what the repurchase agreement is.
b. Date of most recent company acquisition - If the answer to this is a recent
date, then you are reasonably sure that a repurchase program is underway. That is unless
the franchise was repurchased or taken over for contract violation. In the event the
latter is the reason, it is not a negative but a strength indicating franchisor interest
and policing program.
9. FRANCHISE DISTRIBUTION PATTERN
A major distribution pattern in the franchise industry, for both products and services,
is the two-step method. Briefly, this means that the franchisor "packages" the
product and sells it to distributors who in turn sell it to dealers who in turn sell it to
the customer. The distributor usually covers a fairly large area. The dealer covers a very
local area, usually his "backyard market."
a. Exclusive vs. nonexclusive - This can be a surprise since many franchises,
contrary to what people think, are not exclusive as far as territory is concerned. In some
cases, both the distributor and franchisor retain the right to sell direct in the
franchisee territory. Also, they retain the right to sell more than one franchise in a
given territory. There is nothing wrong with a nonexclusive franchise providing you are
aware of the situation before you buy the franchise and want to work this way.
The obvious disadvantage of the nonexclusive franchise is a smaller sales potential.
This should be spelled out to your satisfaction in the contract.
b. Distributorship vs. dealership - Which one of these is your franchise? You
will find the distributorship costs considerably more than the dealership and at the same
time requires more business knowledge and leadership capabilities. If you do not have a
strong business background and financial reserves, stay away from the distributorship.
Start with a dealership. It will be close to home, require less capital, and your time
will be concentrated on the management of that particular location rather than a group of
locations. The return, however, from the dealership is usually less than from the
distributorship. If your franchise is a dealership, get the name and address of your
distributor, visit with him and see whether or not you can get along with him. It will be
the distributor with whom you will conduct much of your business not the
franchisor.
10. FRANCHISE OPERATIONS
Some franchises can be operated from the home, others require office space, others
manufacturing facilities, and others the actual construction of a building. If the
franchise requires office space or the construction of a building, make sure the
franchisor offers guidance and assistance as this is the most important initial role he
will play in getting your business started.
a. What facilities are required - Determine what is needed. This is usually very
evident in the literature that is provided about the franchise. Usually sales
organizations can be operated from home or from shared office space; personnel agencies
require leased office space; retail type franchises require leased store space; and most
fast food outlets and education type franchises require buildings that have to be
constructed.
b. Lease or build - In either situation there are things to look out for. For
example, a lease is usually signed for a specific period of time ..one year, two years,
etc. If it is a lease situation, be sure of the time involved. If the space leased is too
small and not expandable and your business grows to the point you need additional space
and your lease is not up, a penalty will be charged by the building management to break
the lease. Construction is a different situation and a different set of considerations.
Labor problems can delay completion, weather can be a major factor on completion, etc.
These are things that any Realtor can tell you about. You should talk to one you know.
c. Getting started - If your franchise requires that customers come to your
place of business (fast food outlets, home remodeling stores, income tax preparation,
etc.) the critical point of getting started and the pivotal point on the success of your
future business is the feasibility study. This should be done for you by the
franchisor;
if you are told to do it, view this as a negative. The feasibility study considers the
experience gained by the franchisor in setting up successful franchises and applies it to
your market. For example, the following information would be developed and evaluated:
traffic count of various location possibilities, average income of the area, number of
target prospects in the area (fast food would require high concentration of young
families, etc.), and other factors critical to the success of the franchise. Part
experience of the franchisor will tell what is required to assure the possible success of
the franchise. You should make sure that any money "put down" on the basis of
having the feasibility study conducted would be returned to you in the event the results
are negative.
d. Construction - If you must build, once again the franchisor should be
"your right hand man." In fact, he should guide you every step of the way. In
checking what you get for the franchise fee you will find most times that this type of
service is a major reason for a fee at all. If not offered, consider it a negative. Here
you are getting into architecture and design landscaping, contract award, construction,
decor and furnishing, and financing. The subject of financing is critical and will be
covered in Section C-FINANCIAL AND LEGAL.
B. FRANCHISE COMPANY
The primary purpose of this section is to get enough
information about the company to be convinced that they are reputable, financially strong,
and recognized as a leader in the field.
1. THE COMPANY
a. Parent vs. franchise company - As outlined earlier, many times the franchise
company is part of a larger company. In order to check thoroughly this should be known.
Ask for, in addition to the same name and address of the franchise company, the name and
address, if any, of the parent company. Remember that being part of a larger company can
be a very important asset to you in terms of financial stability and visibility. Also, it
won't hurt when dealing with a bank for financing.
b. Public vs. private company - Here you are concerned with the main or parent
company. Find out whether or not you are dealing with a public (stock sold public) or a
private (stock held by a small private group) company. Checking on a public company is a
relatively easy matter, whereas checking on the private company is more difficult.
c. Public company checking - This can be done via published sources since the
SEC requires disclosure of all stock traded public. Determine where the stock is traded.
With this information contact your stock broker, ask him to send you a stock report on
the company. This report will give you all the basic information on the financial
structure of the company you need. Look for rising trends in sales, profits, and earnings
per share. The report will also give you the address of the company and the name of the
officers including the treasurer. Write to him on a postal card requesting a copy of the
most recent quarterly and annual reports, as well as product literature. It is best to
mention that this information is for your investment program. From this literature you
will learn all additional information you need to know about the company. If you do not
have access to a stock broker, consult a local college or public library. Most of them
will have standard reference volumes that contain information on most public companies.
d. Private company checking - This is more difficult than checking public
companies. If you have access to a financial reporting service, request a report on the
company in question. In any event, you should ask the franchisor for references including
a bank and major supplier. Write to each asking specific questions, and in particular,
attempt to determine their financial soundness, also ask some questions the answers to
which have already been supplied by the franchisor. See if the answers are the same. This
acts as a cross check.
C. FINANCIAL AND LEGAL
In this section you want to determine exactly what you are
getting in your franchise package, what you can expect to get in terms of return, and what
does all that fine print say.
1. WHERE TO GET ADVICE
a. Lawyer - Before you sign anything and commit any money you should have a lawyer
advise you and make sure that you understand what you are getting into. Make sure that you
understand what legal liabilities are possible when you get into business and more
importantly make sure these liabilities are covered by insurance, either your own or that
of the franchisor. Check your own lawyer; if you do not have one, check with friends or
another local small businessman and get the name of a qualified lawyer. Make sure the
lawyer you select has interest and experience in advising small businessmen.
b. Financial - The balance of this section will outline questions of a financial
nature. To be meaningful, figures must be interpreted by a "pro" ...an
accountant. As in the case of the lawyer, find one who is knowledgeable in advising small
businessmen. The best way to find a good accountant is to ask local small businessmen for
a recommendation, or perhaps your local Chamber of Commerce might have a suggestion.
c. Management - Business management involves the merging of legal and financial
structures with the overall running of the business. Check your local Chamber of Commerce
to see what they have to offer. Discuss your proposed new business with a successful
businessman and get his views.
2. TOTAL FRANCHISE COST
a. How much money do I have to have to get started - Don't be fooled by claims such
as "Your own business for only 3,500." Make out your own forecast of required
finances and include franchise cost, first year operating expenses, and personal funds
required for up to 2 years. Keep in mind that starting a business does not mean that the
income will automatically come in. In some franchises you might go as long as six months
before a penny flows into your bank account. In any event, there is start up time
regardless of whether it is a personnel agency, fast food outlet, motel, rental agency,
etc. I cite the 2 year period because this is the accepted break even "rule of
thumb" for a new business. A franchise, however, should break even much earlier
because part of what you are buying are proven products, programs, and procedures. In any
event be wary of any franchisor that promises "riches" in less than 2 years. It
just doesn't happen that way.
b. What do I have to pay the franchisor to get started - This consists primarily
of two things ...franchise fee and inventory, and material or construction costs. Make
sure you get a complete answer to this question. It's too late once you have started in
business to discover the true costs are more than you can handle. Let's consider each of
the elements that go to make up the initial amount you pay the franchisor...
c. Franchise fee - Is there a fee as such? If so, how much? What does it
include? What you are paying for in the franchise fee is the right to use and promote a
name and identification program. The value of this depends on how well known the name and
trademark really are. This factor is directly related to marketing and your judgment
should be guided by what you find out in Section E-Marketing. Two other areas are also
covered by this fee ...initial training and home office assistance. Training is covered in
Section D-Training, and Section F-Home Office Support. Ask the opinion of your lawyer and
accountant and make sure you are getting true value for the fee. There are many good
franchises that have no fee and others who will consider negotiating the fee.
d. Services - Are you paying for home office services as part of the initial
franchise cost. If so, what are they? Find out what specifically you will get. Included
here should be complete operating manuals on all phases of the operation. These should be
updated as required. Also, is on the spot assistance of home office experts available? If
so, who, when, what, how long, etc. In addition, find out whether or not the franchisor
offers a computerized accounting system. Accounting is a costly and time consuming chore
if you have to do it yourself, so this service from the franchisor is a plus.
e. Product - Does the initial cost include an "opening" inventory? Is
the price fixed for this and reorder? Is the price competitive? Can you buy elsewhere more
cheaply? Are you permitted to do so? Can you continue to do so? Get an itemized list
including your cost and your cost to your customers. Check and see what percentage of your
total initial cost can be recovered by the resale of the inventory. Also important in this
evaluation is the cost to your customer:
1. Is the price competitive with equal products?
2. Is the quality worth the price?
3. Will the customer be a repeat customer based on the quality of the product?
f. Real Estate - How much of the initial money required is for the purchase of
land and/or construction of your place of business?
g. Equipment and fixtures - Is the cost of start up equipment and fixtures
included in the initial costs? Does the franchisor have an equipment subsidiary from which
you can purchase all equipment, furniture, and supplies at a favorable cost? Are they
priced competitively? Could you save money buying them elsewhere? If so, can you? If all
the supplies and equipment you need are not included in the package price then you must
allow for this in your personal start up costs. Personal service type franchises will
usually require only office furnishings; whereas fast food and education franchises will
usually require a physical plant and various types of equipment and supplies.
h. Other - Always check to see if there are any unique features of the
franchise. If so, are they part of the initial cost. Also, are there any "employee
benefits." Some franchises include benefit programs of life insurance, hospital
insurance, and retirement plans.
i. Is any of the initial cost refundable - Some franchises make it possible to
get back the cost of the franchise fee if the franchise is successful and maintains a
predefined sales volume. This is a good thing to look for ...it provides a real incentive
for the franchise to "stick with it" and "follow the rules." If there
is such a plan, find out exactly what it is and make sure it is covered in your franchise
agreement.
3. FINANCING
a. Is part of the initial cost to the franchisee financed - In most cases where the
start up costs are high the franchisor will finance a portion of the cost. Usually they
will require that you pay the franchise fee in cash. Then on the basis of an acceptable
financial statement they will finance the balance of the start up costs.
b. What is the interest rate - Find out what the interest rate is and check
around and see if you can do better. Remember that many franchise companies have finance
company subsidiaries whose business it is to lend money to the franchisee. Make sure they
are competitive. Check your local bank. Get the best deal you can since every dollar you
can save in interest is a profit dollar for you.
4. FORECAST OF INCOME AND EXPENSES
The forecast, the product or service to be sold, and the written agreement are the
three most important areas that must be considered in the evaluation of a franchise.
Evaluation of the product has already been covered, the agreement will be discussed later
in this section. Remember in computing the forecast of income and expenses that this
should be based on the experience of successful franchises and a conservative forecast of
sales. Don't be carried away by good looking figures that show amazing profits at the end
of one or even two years.
a. Is a forecast of income and expenses provided - Ask this question and get a
copy if the answer is yes. Ask your accountant to review it and if he does not agree with
the franchisor have him prepare one. Review the two opinions with the franchisor and
require that he provide reasonable answers for the differences. Also check some current
franchisees and ask them the same questions. If the franchisor does not supply a valid
forecast of income and expenses in writing or if he cannot give reasonable answers to your
questions, consider these as strong negatives against purchasing the franchise.
b. Does the forecast relate to your market area - This consideration relates
back to the initial section and the question "Needed in your area." If the need
is there the chances are very good that the forecast can be projected to relate to your
market. Make sure, however, that this is the case. Find out if the forecast is based on
experience, if so make sure that the forecast you follow is based on a market equal in
size to your own and compatible with the profile of your market demographics (average age,
income, race, family size, property value, etc.).
c. Does the forecast provide to meet your personal goals - Is there sufficient
income so that you can meet expenses and payroll and at the time pay yourself a salary
that will support your family in the way you want to? Only you know the answer to this. A
good idea is to put the family budget on paper. Start by listing month by month all
regular expenses. Then take annual costs such as medical, clothing, recreation, etc. and
divide them equally assigning a portion to each month. This gives you a monthly
"break even" point for the family. What you will be doing is paying regular
bills as they come up and building an escrow account for the annual type bills. Savings,
when you are building your own business, will probably not be possible for awhile; but
remember every day you operate a successful business you are building an equity which will
be your future.
d. Does the forecast show an adequate return on investment - In starting your
own business you are investing in yourself. Like any investment you expect a return on the
principal invested as well as safety of the principal. See that the return you have set as
your goal is there. (This is in addition to the money you take out as salary.)
e. Does the forecast provide for adequate promotion and personnel - Sales to
obtain orders and people to fill them are the key factors to the success of any business.
One without the other can spell disaster. Make sure that there is adequate money assigned
to the payroll and advertising promotion accounts. The latter will be covered in Section
E-Marketing.
5. WHAT IS THE PROPER LEGAL STRUCTURE FOR MY COMPANY
There are six points, in addition to tax considerations, that are significant in
determining the proper legal structure. They are cost and procedures in starting, size of
risk, continuity of operations, adaptability of administration, influences of applicable
law, and attraction of additional capital. Use your lawyer on determining the answer. The
following are the three main choices for legal structure.
a. Proprietorship - The easiest to begin and end, can have the most flexible
purpose for its operations, need no Government approval, has business profits taxed as
personal income, and makes the owner personally liable for debts and taxes.
b. Partnership - This is the simplest for two or more people to start and
terminate, has the same flexibility of objective, has partners taxed separately, and makes
all except limited partners personally liable for debts and taxes.
c. Corporation - This is the most formal of structures, operates under laws, has
continuous and separate legal life, has its scope of activity and name restricted by a
charter, has the business' profits taxed separately from earnings of executives and
owners, and makes only the company (not the owners nor managers) liable for its debts and
taxes.
6. ARE ALL DETAILS COVERED IN A WRITTEN FRANCHISE CONTRACT
This is the instrument that is the formal understanding between the franchisor and
franchisee. All the major points about your franchise should be spelled out there. Do not
accept the "gentleman's agreement" from a representative of the franchisor
...get it in writing. Have both your lawyer and accountant review the contract before
signing.
a. What to look for - Once again be guided by your lawyer and accountant but be
sure to look for franchise fee; termination, selling, and renewal clauses; cooperative
advertising and promotion funds; does franshisor patent and liability insurance protection
extend To the franchisee; are the home office services spelled out; are all the details as
to commissions, royalties, etc. spelled out; is the training program and who pays for what
spelled out; are financing and financing details spelled out including repayment and
interest; is the territory covered outlined, is it exclusive or nonexclusive, and can the
franchisor or his representative sell direct in your area.
Note: the termination clause should be carefully reviewed to make certain that you have
a sufficient grace period and that your rights as well as those of the franchisor are
represented.
D. TRAINING
One of the unique features of franchising is that it
provides an opportunity for a person to enter a business that is of interest to him but
about which he knows nothing. The franchisor assumes the role of educator and is
responsible for the training and education of the franchisee and his staff. This training
should be very concentrated at the start and should be continuing to keep the franchisee
and his staff current and up to date as far as new products, techniques, methods of
operation, etc.
1. INITIAL TRAINING
This is the critical area. What does the franchisor provide in the way of a training
school to teach you the business of your franchise, how to operate your business, how to
recruit and train personnel, etc. In other words a "How to" course. Usually this
training is of a formal nature and conducted at the home office.
a. Duration - This of course depends on the franchise and how complicated the
business is. It can range from one day to two months. how long is your initial training
program? Equally important here is what happens after you have "graduated." Are
you sent home to run your business; or does a field representative work with you at home
to give you "on the job training" and guide you as you start out. If "on
the job" assistance is not provided by the franchisor this should be considered a
negative. Remember here that while you are gone from home you will not be generating any
income. There are, however, some franchises that pay you while you learn. This should be
the case when the training period is quite long.
b. Cost - This should be part of your franchise contract. Usually your franchise
fee includes the cost of training, supplies, and your personal expenses while training.
Check and make sure that this is the case. See that everything is covered including
transportation, room and board, as well as training and supplies.
c. Curriculum - What is included in the training program? The franchisor should
be able to provide you with a training schedule so that you can see what is included. If
you are dealing with a reputable franchisor you will have no problem here since the
success of your business, and therefore his, is determined by how well you know your
business. Also, as was pointed out before, successful franchises follow a prescribed
program and you can only learn the program through training. Make sure that the following
is covered: franchise operations, sales, finance, promotion, personnel, management,
manufacturing and maintenance (if franchise includes this), and training.
d. Staff Training - In many franchises you will be hiring employees who have to
be trained. Usually this becomes the job of the franchisee and field trainers of the
franchisor. Very seldom does the franchisor provide employee training at the home office.
There are exceptions to this of course. Check and find out which is the case with your
franchise. If the job becomes yours there are two things to find out ..do you get
assistance from the home office in the form of a field representative to help with the
training and what is the training program provided. Training is not as difficult as it may
sound. Most franchisors have "canned training programs" which are on video. The
franchise package usually includes all that is needed to run the program including
manuals, samples, etc. Find out exactly how this will be handled and what you will get.
2. CONTINUING TRAINING
You have to stay up to date to get ahead. It's as simple as that. Things change every
day and your success depends on how current your business is. For example, if you have a
fast food outlet and teenage fads change to the point that what you offer is no longer
"in," what do you do? Once again you look to the franchisor to keep you and your
staff up to date through continuous training.
a. Program - What is the specific program of continuous training. Is there a
formal "refresher course" for franchise principals? Are the staff training
programs updated regularly? Are there seminars? Is there a constant flow of home office
educational materials? Request samples.
b. Cost - What is the cost of the continuing program? Is it part of the
franchise package or does it cost additional?
c. Materials - You should be given a complete list of training materials as well
as an outlining of both initial and continuing training programs.
Suggestion: When you interview present and past franchisees, include training in you
line of questioning. Find out if the franchisor provides the training he promised at the
time of signing the contract and is the training effective and complete?
E. MARKETING
This is the lifeblood of your franchise once you are in
business.
How you market, or sell, your product or services is important because it determines
size of staff, capital required, and most important of all the type of work you will be
devoting your future to. It is important that you understand how you will market your
products or services. In some cases you do selling only, the franchisor provides the
leads; in other cases it is up to the franchisee to generate leads and follow up on them.
Also important is who will be your prospects and customers.
. HOW IS THE PRODUCT OR SERVICE SOLD
There are different methods of selling. For example, a cosmetics franchise might
require cold canvass, door-to-door; a technical school franchise would probably be in-home
by appointment; a bill collecting agency will probably be a combination of direct mail and
telephone; fast food outlets and other retail franchises would be instore sales; and most
franchises selling to business executives would involve selling at the prospect's place of
business by appointment. Which of these, or possibly a combination of two or more, is the
selling method of your franchise?
2. HOW DO YOU GET THE SALES LEADS
This takes various forms. In some cases the franchisor through national advertising,
public relations, and direct mail generates all the leads and turns them over to the
franchisee for follow-up. The other extreme is that the franchisee has to secure his own
leads either with or without cooperative advertising support from the franchisor. (If this
is the case, is it provided for in the forecast?) An important thing to remember is that a
satisfied customer is your best advertisement. There should be a technique to get referral
prospects from your satisfied customers. Other methods of securing sales leads are
telephone solicitation and trade show booths. Trade show attendance is usually handled by
the franchisor or a distributor.
3. WHO ARE THE PROSPECTS FOR THE PRODUCTS OR SERVICES
It is imperative that you know who your prospects are. In most businesses an accurate
rule of thumb is 20 percent of your customers account for 80 percent of your business. You
need to know who that 20 percent is for your franchise. In consumer products the profile
of your best customer will probably be described by age, sex, and income; whereas your
best business customer would be described by type of business, annual sales volume, number
of employees, and title of purchaser. Ask for a profile of the prospect. If this
information is not available it should be viewed as a negative.
4. WHAT IS THE NATIONAL ADVERTISING PROGRAM OF THE FRANCHISOR
The answer you get to this question depends on the way you ask it. Most franchises are
sold via ads much like the one you probably answered. Many franchisors will include the
franchise sales advertising program as part of the answer to how much they are spending in
advertising. Others will include the dollar value of publicity appearing in newspapers,
magazines or on radio and TV. What you want to know is what is the national advertising
program promoting the products or services of the franchise to the prospective customers.
Public media such as television, radio, newspaper, magazine, and outdoor are important to
the visibility of the product and franchise trademark. Remember the franchise fee you pay
is for the use of these; and therefore make sure they are properly and effectively
promoted. Direct mail if it is local or supporting franchise sales should not be
considered as part of the national program. Samples of the national advertising should be
available to prospective franchisees. You should find out where the advertising runs so
that you can look for it and form your own opinion as to its effectiveness.
5. WHAT KIND OF ADVERTISING AND PROMOTION SUPPORT IS AVAILABLE FOR THE LOCAL
FRANCHISEE
This is the local advertising and promotion program in support of your franchise in
your market. This should be an extension of the national program ...make sure it is. For
this reason the franchisor should supply packaged programs for your use. These programs
should include ad mats, radio scripts, TV commercials, sample media programs, direct mail
programs, point of purchase material, sample publicity releases and accompanying
photographs, etc. Refer to the section on finance for a discussion of coop advertising.
The establishment of your business is news. Does the franchisor provide plans for a grand
opening; including advertising, publicity, etc. Ask to see a sample kit.
6. SHOULD YOU HAVE AN ADVERTISING AGENCY
Probably not because part of the franchise package should be a tested advertising
program along with complete instructions as to how to implement it. You should get some
assistance from the franchisor's field man and possibly his advertising agency. In some
cases, particularly in larger cities, the national advertising agency of the franchisor
might have a branch office in your city. If this is the case, you can probably get
assistance from them at no cost other than the normal cost of the advertising space or
time. Check with the franchisor to see if this assistance comes from the field man or the
advertising agency.
F. HOME OFFICE SUPPORT
Even though you will be in business for yourself your
success is tied directly to the franchisor and therefore you should look to your home
office as a branch manager of a company would look to his home office. For the most part
the home office of the franchisor will consist primarily of people as opposed to
manufacturing facilities, warehousing, etc. You will probably find that the number of home
office personnel might seem low when compared to companies with company owned distribution
systems. It is important to keep in mind, therefore, that it is not quantity but quality
that is important to you. For example, a technical school franchise would be expected to
have persons on staff who have backgrounds in education; also there should be education
experts serving either as directors or consultants. In this section therefore you want to
find out the qualifications of the franchisor in respect to the product or service of the
franchise.
1. PRINCIPALS AND DIRECTORS
a. Principals - Who are the key persons in the day to day operation of the
business? What are their backgrounds and accomplishments? If all have financial and or
sales backgrounds and no particular experience in the field of the franchise this should
be considered a negative. Look for sound business and financial experience and a depth of
expertise in the business of the franchise. For example, if the franchise is in the
automotive field you would expect to find that some of the principals came from automotive
companies. If the franchise is in the motel field you would expect experience from one of
the major motel chains.
b. Directors - Who are the members of the board of directors? These board
members usually serve without pay and many times are majority stockholders. What you are
looking for are directors who have backgrounds related to the business of the franchise.
The more the better for you. Also it is always good to find the following on the board:
officer of a bank, professor of a university, and officers of major companies.
2. CONSULTANTS
a. Consultants - Somewhere in between the principals and the directors fit the
consultants. These are people who are specialists in specific fields and sell their
services on a retainer basis to companies needing strength in the particular area the
consultant serves. There are transportation consultants, medical consultants, marketing
consultants, management consultants, etc. Check and see if the franchisor has "beefed
up home office capability" with any consultants. Find out who they are and a little
bit about them.
3. SERVICE DEPARTMENTS
a. Service departments - These departments are what the title says ...service. They
are in existence to be of service to the franchisee so it is in your best interests to
find out what they are, who is in charge, what is his background, and the specific
services they provide. Other sections have covered what services you may want. Critical
departments to look for are: finance and accounting, advertising and promotion, sales and
marketing, research and development, real-estate, construction, personnel and training,
manufacturing, and operations. In addition to the departments covered earlier two others
mentioned above are very important. Research and Development is the lifeblood to any
organization since it is charged with plotting the future of the product or service line.
This should be an active department with an adequate budget. Also the operations
department (many other names are assigned to this) with which you will have much of your
contact is most important. This is the department that is charged with the responsibility
of liaison between franchisor and franchisee. In the case of a distribution set up, the
distributor works through the operations department and the local franchisee through the
distributor. In any event make sure that there is a clear channel of communication between
you and your distributor or franchisor.
4. FIELD SUPPORT
a. Field Support - This is covered in the sections on training and marketing as it
relates to those specific subjects. What you want to find out is specifically what you get
in terms of help at your place of business from the franchisor. You will note that most
franchise package benefits mention field support, but the questions are when, how often,
who, what does he do. It would be good to get the name of this person and talk to him to
get an understanding of what he really can do for you.
Franchise Profile
The questions of the Franchise Index are repeated
here without the discussion. When these questions are answered, they will form the profile
of the franchise that you are evaluating. Before you actually begin to prepare the profile
of a specific franchise, read through the Franchise Index and relate the questions to the
corresponding discussion there. Then, try to determine what you need in a franchise.
As you read through the questions, you will notice that some of them will require you
to do a little homework before you can effectively evaluate a franchise. For example, you
must know what your personal living expenses are before you can determine if the forecast
of profits is sufficient. Depending on how much you know about the business of the
franchise, you will have to think about what you will need in a training program. You
might also think about and make decisions about how much capital you have and what
financing you will need.
On the other hand, some questions must be researched before you can evaluate them. For
example, the franchisor must supply the names of franchisees that failed. the Franchise
Index suggests two sources of information for the reasons why the franchisees failed.
Also, the answers to some questions must be weighed against the entire package. What you
will need in advertising will depend on the type of product, the area to be serviced, etc.
As you prepare your profile, note that the questions become increasingly more specific.
An early negative reply to one of the more general questions might carry enough weight to
discourage further consideration of that franchise. Be aware of this possibility and you
may save considerable time and effort in the information gathering stage of the
evaluation. It is suggested that you make a copy of the Franchise Profile for each
franchise you intend to evaluate. By having a similar format for each franchise profile,
it will be easier to compare them.
FRANCHISE PROFILE
A. FRANCHISE GENERAL
1. IS THE PRODUCT OR SERVICE:
Yes / No
1. IS THE PRODUCT OR SERVICE:
Yes / No
a. Considered reputable ____ ____
b. Part of a growing market ____ ____
c. Needed in your area ____ ____
d. Of interest to you ____ ____
e. Safe ____ ____
Protected ____ ____
Covered by guarantee ____ ____
f. Carry the name of a well known personality ____ ____
Sound franchise without well known personality ____ ____
2. IS THE FRANCHISE:
a. Local ____ ____
Regional ____ ____
National ____ ____
International ____ ____
b. Full time ____ ____
Part time ____ ____
Full time possible in future ____ ____
3. EXISTING FRANCHISES:
a. How long was the company in business before the first franchise was awarded? ______
years.
b. What date was the company founded and what date was the first franchise awarded?
Company founded _____. First franchise awarded _____.
c. Number currently in operation or under construction? _____ . Information on those to
contact:
Franchise # 1: Owner __________________
Address __________________
Telephone __________________
Date Started __________________
Franchise #2: Owner __________________
Address __________________
Telephone __________________
Date Started __________________
Franchise #3: Owner __________________
Address __________________
Telephone __________________
Date Started __________________
Franchise #4: Owner __________________
Address __________________
Telephone __________________
Date Started __________________
d. How many franchises are planned for the next 12 months (not including those awarded
and not yet in operation)? __________________
4. WHY HAVE FRANCHISES FAILED?
a. How many franchises have failed? __________________ How many of these have been in
the last 2 years? __________________
b. Why have franchises failed?
Franchisor Reasons: __________________
Franchisee: ______________________________________________________
5. FRANCHISE IN LOCAL MARKET AREA
a. Has a franchise ever been awarded in this area? __________________. If so and if it
is still in operation:
Owner __________________
Address __________________
Telephone __________________ Date started __________________
If so and if it is no longer in operation:
Person involved __________________
Address __________________
Date started __________________ Date ended __________________
Reasons for failure __________________
How many inquiries have you had for your franchise from my area in the past 6 months?
__________________ .
6. WHAT PRODUCT OR SERVICE WILL BE ADDED TO FRANCHISE PACKAGE?
a. Within 12 months? __________________
b. Within 2 years? __________________
c. Within 2 to 5 years? __________________
7. COMPETITION?
a. What is my competition? __________________
8. ARE ALL FRANCHISES INDEPENDENTLY OWNED?
a. Of the total outlets, _____ are franchised, and _____ are company owned.
b. If some outlets are company owned did they start out this way _____ or were they
repurchased from a franchisee _____. Date of most recent company acquisition
__________________ .
9. FRANCHISE DISTRIBUTION PATTERN:
a. Is the franchise exclusive _____ or nonexclusive _____.
b. Is the franchise a distributorship _____ or a dealership _____. If it is a
dealership who is the distributor in my area:
Name __________________
Address __________________
How long has he been a distributor __________________
10. FRANCHISE OPERATIONS:
a. and b. What facilities are required and do I lease or build.
Operated out of home _____ Build Lease
Office ____ ____
Building ____ ____
Manufacturing facility ____ ____
Warehouse ____ ____
c and d. Getting started ... who is responsible for what?
Franchisor Franchisee
Feasibility Study _________ _________
Design _________ _________
Construction _________ _________
Furnishing _________ _________
Financing _________ _________
B. FRANCHISE COMPANY
1. THE COMPANY:
1. THE COMPANY:
a. What is the name and address of the parent company if different than the franchise
company:
Name ________________
Address ______________
b. Is the parent company public _____ or private _____.
c. If the company is public where is the stock traded: ______________________________
d. If the company is private the president is _____________.
The following bank can be used as a reference.
Name ___________________
Address _________________
Person to contact __________
C. FINANCIAL AND LEGAL
1. WHERE TO GET ADVICE:
a. lawyer
Name _________________
Address _________________
Telephone ________________
b. Financial
Name _________________
Address _________________
Telephone _________________
c. Management
Name _________________
Address _________________
Telephone _________________
2. TOTAL FRANCHISE COST:
a. How much money do I have to have to get started?
Item Amount
Franchise start up (2b) ________
First year operating ________
First year personal ________
TOTAL ________
b. through h. What do I have to pay the franchisor to get started? ________
Basis of cost:
Item Amount
Franchise Fee ________
Services ________
Product ________
Real Estate ________
Equipment ________
c. Is any of the initial franchise cost refundable? ___________ .
If so, on what basis? _______________
3. FINANCING:
a. Is part of the initial cost to the franchisee financed? __________.
If so how much ______________, this represents ___________% of the total initial cost.
b. What is the interest rate? ______ %. When does financing have to be paid back?
________
4. FORECAST OF INCOME AND EXPENSES:
a. Is a forecast of income and expenses provided? ______.
Is it:
based on actual franchise operations? _____
based on a franchisor outlet? _____
purely estimated? _____
b. through e. If a forecast is provided does it:
Yes / No
Relate to your market area ____ ____
Meet your personal goals ____ ____
Provide adequate return on investment ____ ____
Provide for adequate promotion and personnel ____ ____
5. WHAT IS THE BEST LEGAL STRUCTURE FOR MY COMPANY?
a. through c.
Proprietorship ______
Partnership ________
Corporation ________
6. ARE ALL DETAILS COVERED IN A WRITTEN FRANCHISE CONTRACT?
Yes ____ No _____ (get copy for lawyer and accountant review)
a. What to look for - are these included?
Yes / No
Franchise fee ___ ___
Termination ___ ___
Selling and renewal ___ ___
Advertising and promotion ___ ___
Patent and liability protection ___ ___
Home office services ___ ___
Commissions and royalties ___ ___
Training ___ ___
Financing ___ ___
Territory ___ ___
Exclusive vs. nonexclusive ___ ___
D. TRAINING
1. INITIAL TRAINING:
a. Does franchisor provide formal initial training? _____
If so how long does it last? _________
b. Cost
Yes / No
Included in franchise cost ___ ___
Includes all materials ___ ___
Includes transportation ___ ___
Includes room and board ___ ___
If not included in franchise cost what is total cost including all outlined
above?____________
c. What does the training course include?
Yes / No
Franchise operations ___ ___
Sales ___ ___
Finance ___ ___
Promotion ___ ___
Personnel ___ ___
Management ___ ___
Manufacturing and maintenance ___ ___
Training ___ ___
d. How do you train your initial staff? Is a training program provided?____. Does the
franchisor make available a staff member from the home office to assist? ______. What
materials are included in the staff' training program?
__________________________________________
2. CONTINUING TRAINING:
a. thru c. What is the continuing program? Is there any cost? ______. If so how much
_______. Are there any special materials or equipment required? __________ . If so what?
__________.
What is the cost to the franchisee? __________________________.
E. MARKETING:
1. How is the product or service sold?
Yes / No
In home - appointment ___ ___
In home - cold ___ ___
Telephone ___ ___
In store or place of business ___ ___
At business - appointment ___ ___
At business - cold ___ ___
Mail ___ ___
2. How do you get the sales leads
Yes / No
Franchisor ___ ___
Franchisee ___ ___
Both ___ ___
Advertising ___ ___
Direct Mail ___ ___
Telephone ___ ___
Trade Shows ___ ___
3. Who are the prospects for the products or services?
Outline a brief profile: ________________________________________________________
4.What is the national advertising program of the franchisor?
a. What it the national advertising budget? _________________.
b. What are the primary advertising media?
Television ________
Radio ________
Outdoor ________
Newspaper ________
Magazine ________
Direct Mail ________
5. What kind of advertising and promotion support is available for the local franchise?
Yes / No
Is a packaged advertising program available? ____ ____
Is there a co-op advertising program? ____ ____
Is there a grand opening package? ____ ____
6. Should you have an advertising agency? ___________
F. HOME OFFICE SUPPORT
1. PRINCIPALS AND DIRECTORS:
1. PRINCIPALS AND DIRECTORS:
a. Who are the key persons in the day to day operation of the business:
Name
Title
Background
____________ ________ ____________________
____________ ________ ____________________
____________ ________ ____________________
____________ ________ ____________________
____________ ________ ____________________
b. Who are the directors (do not include those from a. above)?
Name
Business Association
________________ _____________________
________________ _____________________
________________ _____________________
2.CONSULTANTS:
a. Who are the consultants to the company?
Name
Business Specialty
________________ _____________________
________________ _____________________
3. SERVICE DEPARTMENTS:
a. What service departments do you have? Yes / No
Finance and accounting ____ ____
Advertising and promotion ____ ____
Sales and marketing ____ ____
Research and development ____ ____
Real estate ____ ____
Construction ____ ____
Personnel and training ____ ____
Manufacturing and operations ____ ____
Purchasing ____ ____
______________ ____ ____
______________ ____ ____
4. FIELD SUPPORT:
a. Do you have field man assigned to working with a set number of franchises?
__________
Who would be assigned to my franchise? __________
How many other franchises is he assigned to? __________
May I contact him? __________ |